Big Box of Knitting Fails – Bad Yarn Substitution!

Big Box of Knitting Fails – Bad Yarn Substitution!

Big Box of Knitting FailsFor those of you that have taken classes with me, you know all about “Patty’s Big Box of Knitting Fails”. I seem to have an example of something tragic I’ve done in my knitting for nearly everything I’m teaching. So, I’m launching a new blog series to dig into my knitting boo boos. Today’s episode . . .

Bad Yarn Substitution = to felt or not to felt

About 12 years ago, I thought I’d make a fast, fun, felted scarf. The pattern was all in stockinette, and then felted to make a cozy scarf. It featured stripes of white and black yarn held together with stripes of the solid white. The felting made the black and white flecks appear in a random fashion, and it kind of widened out at the doubled yarn sections and narrowed a bit for the white sections.

No brainer right . . . unless you grab a black 100% wool from your stash and a white 100% acrylic from your stash. That’s right folks, acrylic doesn’t felt. (BTW: forgive the low res pic. This was a long time ago, so it was not taken on a fancy camera, might have even been – gasp – film)

Bad yarn substitution

What resulted was a kind of bizarre little item that rolled at the sides for every acrylic stripe and then kind of morphed into 1/2 felted, 1/2 not stripes.

Sigh.

Don’t make my  mistake. Learn about the Secrets of Yarn Substitution.

YarnSub

Check Out These 4 Best New Knitting Books of 2025 from My Talented Friends (Perfect Gifts!)

Share:

Sales & Specials

Get My Blog Posts in Your Email or Blog-Reader

Proin malesuada sit amet arcu ac ultrices.

Related Articles

My Twenty-Year Journey to Patty Lyons’ Knitting ER

From the Introduction: “Many years ago, I managed a small yarn shop in the West Village of New York City. I often found a knitter ...
Read More

Palm Canyon Video Sweater Class – KAL

Join me for the Palm Canyon KAL! It’s a fun knit with an integrated sleeve and tons of options. There are two different yarns, two ...
Read More

AffiKNITy 2026 Recap: Yarn, Laughs, Rocking Chairs, and a Little Toilet Paper Knitting

We’re back from Otesaga just over a month, and I’m still thinking about it. Every year I come home from AffiKNITy feeling refilled. Not just ...
Read More